Pros & Cons for Curly Hair:

Co-Washing Pros: Maintains moisture and natural oils, leading to softer, more hydrated curls. Can reduce frizz and increase curl definition since hair isn’t stripped. Great for very dry hair types (e.g., type 4 coils) that need all the moisture they can get. If you wash frequently (say you work out daily), co-washing allows frequent refreshing without as much damage as shampooing daily would do. Saves time in routine because you condition and cleanse in one step.

Co-Washing Cons: Can cause buildup if used exclusively, especially at the scalp. Conditioner is not as effective at removing heavy oils or styling product accumulation. Fine or low-density hair might get too weighed down with continuous co-washing. These hair types often need a cleaner scalp to have volume. Not ideal if you have scalp issues that require thorough cleansing (e.g., if you’re prone to dandruff, completely skipping shampoo might exacerbate it). Hair might feel greasy or not truly clean after a while. Many co-washers report that they need to clarify occasionally to remove co-wash buildup. It’s recommended to use a clarifying shampoo every few weeks in conjunction, otherwise you can get “co-wash gunk” where hair gets limp and scalp gets waxy. Does not remove silicones or certain styling polymers well. If you use silicone serums or heavy gels, you’ll definitely need to shampoo periodically.

Shampooing Pros: Thoroughly cleanses removes dirt, sweat, buildup effectively. Your scalp will likely feel cleaner and less chance of blocked follicles. Essential for clarifying only a shampoo (maybe a strong one) can truly reset hair if it’s overloaded with product or minerals. Can be done less frequently since it cleans so well (some curly people only shampoo once every week or two, co-washing or just conditioning in between). Scalp health: if you find co-washing leaves your scalp itchy or filmy, adding shampoo fixes that. For those with wavy or fine curls, shampooing (especially a gentle one) can actually boost volume and prevent hair from looking stringy or oily.

Shampooing Cons: Risk of drying out hair, especially if using sulfate shampoos or washing too often. This can lead to frizz, breakage, and loss of curl pattern (dry curls = looser, less springy curls). Some shampoos contain other harsh ingredients (like certain alcohols) that can strip or cause irritation. Even sulfate-free shampoos, if used very frequently, might be more cleaning than a very dry curl type needs. Historically, many shampoos had silicones or heavy conditioning agents to counteract sulfates those silicones can then build up if not fully washed out (a cycle). Many newer curly-safe shampoos avoid that though.

Best of Both Worlds a Combined Approach: For many curly folks, the sweet spot is not strictly one or the other, but a balance: Alternate: For example, co-wash on one wash day, then use a sulfate-free shampoo on the next wash day. Or co-wash for your mid-week refresh, shampoo on the weekend. Scalp vs Length: Some do a hybrid in one session: they use a little shampoo on the scalp only, and co-wash/condition the lengths. The shampoo cleans the roots, the co-wash cleans/conditions the rest. Clarify as needed: If you mainly co-wash, plan a clarify with a stronger shampoo about once a month or anytime hair feels coated. Low-Poo (gentle shampoo) as default: Another approach is skip co-wash and instead use a mild, sulfate-free shampoo regularly (maybe diluted even). These often contain gentler surfactants or lower levels of anionic surfactants, so they cleanse but don’t leave hair totally stripped. Many curly experts recommend this for wavies or anyone who didn’t love full co-washing. For instance, “wash 2-3 times a week with a sulfate-free, low-lather shampoo” is advice from curl specialists because that keeps scalp healthy without the dryness. Co-wash in between washes: If you feel the need to wet your hair or refresh more often than you should shampoo, co-wash is a great in-between. E.g., you shampoo once a week, but mid-week after a workout you co-wash to avoid salt/sweat buildup but still be gentle.

Consider Your Hair Type and Lifestyle: If you have fine, oily, or wavy hair (Type 2): You might lean toward using a shampoo more often. Fine and wavy hair can get weighed down by co-washing in fact, some wavies who tried curly girl method exclusively co-washing found their hair went limp or greasy. A common recommendation for wavies is to alternate co-wash with low-poo. For example, one routine might be co-wash twice, then on the third wash use a gentle shampoo (this exact 2 co-washes + 1 low-poo rotation is mentioned in wavy hair guides). That way, you get moisture benefits but also regular deep cleans to avoid buildup. If you have thick, dry, curly or coily hair (Type 3c, 4): You may benefit more from co-washing because your hair craves moisture and your scalp might not produce a ton of oil. Many with tight curls co-wash frequently (some even every few days) and only shampoo occasionally. But still, pay attention to your scalp if co-washing only, ensure you’re scrubbing well and clarify when needed. Some find doing two co-washes and then a gentle shampoo in the same session helps (i.e., co-wash first for moisture, then quick shampoo on scalp, then condition sometimes called “double cleansing” for curls). If your scalp is very oily or you have dandruff: Completely eliminating shampoo might cause issues. There are medicated shampoos or simply the need for real surfactants to control yeast (in dandruff). In such cases, it might be best to shampoo, but choose a moisturizing one and maybe focus it on scalp while letting lather just cleanse the ends lightly. Or co-wash most washes but still do your medicated shampoo once a week, etc. Lifestyle: If you sweat a lot (gym daily) or are in environments where your hair gets dirty (outdoors, pollution), you might need more cleansing. Co-washing can handle sweat salt to an extent but if you feel icky, a quick shampoo might do better. Conversely, if you’re mostly indoors and don’t produce much scalp oil, you can go longer with just co-washing.

Addressing Common Fears: “Won’t co-washing make my scalp dirty or hair fall out?” If done properly, co-washing can keep your scalp healthy. The massaging action is key to avoid buildup. However, some people do experience shedding if pores get clogged. If you see more hair fall after prolonged co-washing, it may be time to shampoo or at least clarify. It’s not that co-washing inherently causes hair loss, but an imbalance can contribute to scalp issues. So always monitor how your scalp responds. “If I never shampoo, what about silicone buildup?” That’s why CG method forbids silicones when co-washing. If you want to co-wash only, you must also use silicone-free products or else you’ll accumulate gunk that co-wash can’t remove. If you do use a non-CG product occasionally, just plan a sulfate shampoo “reset wash” to get it out. “My hair feels greasy when I co-wash, what am I doing wrong?” You might not be scrubbing enough, or you might not be rinsing enough, or simply your hair might not like co-wash alone. Fine hair in particular often feels coated with co-wash. Solution: incorporate a gentle shampoo more often. Or try different co-wash products some are lighter. Also, ensure you’re using enough co-wash and spending several minutes on the massage co-washing isn’t a quick slather and rinse; it usually requires working the conditioner in thoroughly (since no lather to spread it).

Example Cleansing Routine 1 (Mixed): Sarah has 3a curls, medium thickness. She shampoos once a week with a sulfate-free curl shampoo to deeply clean. Mid-week, she co-washes after a gym session. This keeps her scalp comfortable and her curls hydrated. She notices if she tries to only co-wash for two weeks straight, her roots get a bit limp so she doesn’t skip that weekly shampoo.

Example Cleansing Routine 2 (Co-wash heavy): Mia has 4b coils. She co-washes twice a week and rarely uses shampoo, maybe only if she accidentally uses a product with silicone. Her hair retains moisture much better since switching from weekly shampoo to mostly co-washing. She makes sure to clarify with a stronger sulfate shampoo about once a month to prevent any slow buildup (and each time she loves how bouncy her curls get after a clarify + deep condition, proving that occasional shampoo is beneficial).

Example Cleansing Routine 3 (Shampoo heavy): Alex has 2b waves and a fairly oily scalp. Co-washing made her hair flat. So she shampoo 2-3 times a week with a gentle moisturizing shampoo, and rarely co-washes. Instead, she focuses on using a good conditioner and leave-in after shampooing to keep her waves hydrated. Her scalp is happier with regular shampoo, and her waves still look good due to the sulfate-free formula and conditioning steps.

The bottom line is finding what works for you. And remember, you don’t have to join a camp of “only co-wash” or “only shampoo”. You can customize.

Tips for Co-Washing Successfully: Use plenty of co-wash product. You often need a big palmful to have enough to massage your whole scalp. Spend a solid 3-5 minutes massaging your scalp with the co-wash. Treat it like you would shampoo in terms of thoroughness, except it won’t lather, so you manually have to move it around. Rinse really well leftover conditioner on scalp can cause greasiness. If you feel your hair is getting limp, it’s time to shampoo or clarify. Use a clarifying shampoo or exfoliating scalp scrub periodically.

Tips for Shampooing Without Drying Out Curls: Use sulfate-free whenever possible. If you must use a sulfate shampoo (e.g., to remove silicone buildup), follow with an intensive conditioning or deep treatment. Dilute your shampoo with a little water in a applicator bottle so it distributes easier and is less concentrated. Focus on scalp; don’t pile hair up or rough up the ends. After shampoo, always follow with a good conditioner and maybe a leave-in. That restores moisture and ensures curls won’t be left stripped.

Conclusion: In the co-wash vs shampoo debate, the winner is… both! They are not enemies but tools. For curly hair, moisture is crucial but so is a clean, healthy scalp. Many curly experts and communities have evolved to a more balanced view: use co-washing as a moisturizing cleanse and shampooing as a periodic deeper cleanse. The “best” cleansing method for your curls might be co-washing most of the time and shampooing occasionally, or shampooing regularly with a very gentle product, or anything in between. If you tried one method and your hair isn’t happy, don’t be afraid to pivot. For instance, if you only co-wash and notice dullness, integrate a gentle shampoo once a week you might find your curls actually improve (since removal of buildup lets them spring up better). Conversely, if you’ve been shampooing every other day and wonder why your curls are frizzy, try swapping some shampoos with co-wash sessions to see if your hair retains more moisture and behaves better.

The ultimate goal is clean, hydrated curls. For many, that means using both methods strategically. And always listen to your hair and scalp: they will tell you if they’re over-cleansed (dry, squeaky hair, irritated scalp) or under-cleansed (greasy, limp, itchy scalp). Adjust accordingly. With the right balance, you’ll enjoy curls that are not only beautifully moisturized and defined, but also fresh and healthy at the roots. So embrace co-washing as a gentle wash day friend, but keep that shampoo in your arsenal for when you need a real reset your curls can indeed have the best of both worlds!

Curl Types Explained for 2024